Ironing vs Redraw: What Each Pass Does to a Deep Drawn Wall
Redrawing and ironing are two different passes on a deep drawn shell, and they change different things. A redraw pulls an already-drawn cup through a smaller die to reduce its diameter and gain depth; it changes the geometry of the part. Ironing pushes the wall through a gap narrower than the sheet thickness, squeezing it thinner and straighter; it changes the wall, not the bore. Most deep parts use both, in that order, and the confusion comes from the fact that they often sit in adjacent stations of the same press line. If the drawing calls for a part that is deeper than one stroke can make, you need a redraw. If it calls for a controlled wall thickness along that depth, you need ironing.
We build both into our own draw schedules on 5–500 ton presses, to 150 mm depth from 0.15–3.0 mm sheet. General ID tolerance on our tooling is ±0.05 mm; on an ironed, guided wall we hold ±0.02 mm. Those are measured figures from our line, not handbook ranges. This page is about reading a draw schedule and knowing which pass is doing what.
What a redraw actually changes
The first draw has a ceiling. The limiting draw ratio — blank diameter divided by punch diameter — is the largest reduction a sheet survives in one stroke before it tears at the punch radius. We use 2.1–2.2 for DC04, 1.85–2.05 for 304 stainless steel and 1.80–1.95 for 5052 aluminium, measured on our own presses. A part past that ceiling cannot be forced through in one hit, so the shell is drawn to an intermediate diameter and then pulled again through a smaller die.
Each redraw reduces the diameter and adds height, roughly conserving the volume of metal in the wall. It also spends ductility. Cold work raises the yield strength and lowers what is left for the next pass, so a three- or four-stage route often needs an anneal between stages. That is the real cost of a redraw: not just another die station, but the heat treatment, the handling and the extra inspection that go with it. Our LDR reference gives the per-material ceilings and the multi-draw coefficients we plan from.
Redraws are also where a rectangular or non-symmetric shell gets difficult. Every corner sees a different effective ratio, so the stage plan has to be balanced section by section. The irregular parts guide covers that case; a round cup is the easy version.
What an ironing pass actually changes
Ironing is a thickness operation. The cup sits on a punch and is pushed through a die whose clearance is deliberately less than the incoming wall. The metal in the wall is compressed and extruded upward, so the cup gets taller, the wall gets thinner and, more importantly, uniform. The inside diameter is set by the punch and stays essentially where it was. What changes is the outside diameter and the gauge.
That is why ironing is specified when the wall is a functional dimension. A pressure cup, a long sleeve, a battery can or a telescoping tube cannot tolerate the thickness gradient a normal draw leaves behind. On a typical production route we take a shell drawn from 1.0 mm sheet down to 0.78 mm on the wall, and hold that wall to ±0.02 mm. The 304 pressure cup case study is the worked example: 120 mm deep, single draw plus ironing, with the wall data recorded on the first article. The cans, caps and sleeves family shows where ironing gets used for long sleeves that live or die on wall consistency.
Ironing needs lubrication, a clean surface and a guided tool. It also needs a wall that has not been work-hardened past what the pass can take, so the position of the ironing station in the schedule matters. Put it too late and the metal has run out of ductility; put it too early and the following redraw undoes the thickness you just set.
Ironing vs redraw side by side
| Redraw | Ironing | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | Reduce diameter, add depth | Reduce and equalise wall thickness, add some height |
| What the die gap does | Accommodates the sheet; the shell is pulled through a smaller diameter | Is set smaller than the incoming wall on purpose |
| Inside diameter | Changes — this is the point of the pass | Stays with the punch |
| Wall thickness | Redistributes; still a gradient from base to rim | Becomes a controlled, repeatable gauge |
| Material state | Uses ductility, often needs an interstage anneal | Needs ductility left in the wall and good lubrication |
| Typical tolerance we quote | ±0.05 mm ID | ±0.02 mm on the wall with guided tooling |
| Failure mode if overdone | Split at the punch radius | Galling, scoring, or a wall that tears on the punch |
| Where it sits in the route | Between the first draw and the final size | Usually after the last redraw, before trim |
Reading the wall map before you release the drawing
A drawn wall is not one number. It thins near the bottom radius, swells towards the rim, and on anisotropic sheet it ears. Ironing flattens that map; a redraw reshapes it. So the drawing should say what the wall dimension means: a minimum anywhere on the shell, a nominal at a stated height, or a hard gauge for a sealing land. We have seen prints where a designer copied the incoming sheet gauge into the wall callout, which is unmanufacturable on a deep draw without an ironing pass, and pointless on a part that does not need one.
The second thing to settle is how it will be measured. Ultrasonic gauging, a sectioned first article and a micrometer on a trimmed ring do not give the same answer on a curved wall. We record the method with the wall data, because a ±0.02 mm claim without one is not a claim.
When a route needs both passes
Most tall thin shells do. A 5052 aluminium battery can at 0.15 mm wall is drawn across several stages with intermediate anneals, and the wall is sized at the end; the prismatic cell can case walks through that schedule. A shallow 60 mm cup in DC04 might need one draw and a trim, with no redraw and no ironing at all. The tooling cost between those two parts is an order of magnitude apart, and the difference is entirely in the stage plan.
We make the tools in house, so changing an ironing clearance or adding a redraw station is a shop-floor decision rather than a purchase order. That matters during try-out, where the first articles tell you whether the bead map and the anneal point were right. The sixteen process routes lists where reverse draws, taper draws and ironing appear in practice, and the calculator set gives a starting blank diameter and force before any steel is cut.
What we do not claim
We do not claim ±0.02 mm as a general tolerance for deep drawn parts. That figure needs an ironing pass on a guided tool, on a geometry that will hold it; a wide shallow rectangular cover will not. Where the print asks for it, we say at quotation whether the shape can carry it.
We do not publish a universal thinning percentage per ironing pass. The reduction we can take depends on the alloy, the incoming gauge, the lubrication and how much cold work is already in the wall, and we set it per part during try-out. Nor do we publish leak-rate or autoclave-cycle numbers; we have not run those tests to a published standard on our line.
We do not claim a redraw can replace an anneal. If the metal has work-hardened, another pass will tear it. And we do not claim 6xxx aluminium behaves like 5xxx in a multi-stage route; those grades are for shallow forming with T6 applied afterwards, as the material selection guide explains.
Standards and further reading
- ASM Handbook, Volume 14B: Metalworking — Sheet Forming — deep drawing, redraw practice, ironing and formability testing in one reference.
- ASTM E646 — tensile strain-hardening exponent (n-value) of sheet metal, the property that governs how much cold work a stage can take.
- ASTM E517 — plastic strain ratio (r-value), which predicts earing and therefore how much trim a drawn rim needs.
- DIN 8584 — classification of forming operations; drawing and ironing sit in different subgroups.
- ISO 9001 — the quality management standard our first-article wall records and inspection method are kept under.
Frequently asked questions
Which pass changes the bore and which pass changes the gauge?
A redraw reduces the cup diameter and increases its depth, using a smaller die and spending some of the material’s remaining ductility. Ironing squeezes the wall through a clearance narrower than the sheet, making it thinner, straighter and more uniform without changing the inside diameter. Deep parts normally need redraws first to reach depth, then an ironing pass to set the wall.
If I iron a cup, does its bore stay the same size?
Yes, essentially. The shell sits on a punch during ironing, so the bore stays with the punch while the outside diameter and the wall thickness change. That is why ironing is the pass to specify when a sleeve has to fit a mating part on its bore but also needs a controlled wall. A redraw, by contrast, changes the diameter on purpose.
What reduction do you allow on a single ironing station?
It depends on the alloy, the starting gauge, the lubricant and how much cold work is already in the wall, so we set the reduction per part during try-out rather than quoting a universal percentage. On one published production part we take 304 stainless steel from 1.0 mm to 0.78 mm and hold ±0.02 mm on the wall. A print that needs more reduction than one pass can carry gets a second station, not a bigger guess.
At what point does cold work force a furnace step into the draw schedule?
Each draw cold-works the metal: yield strength rises and the ductility left for the next pass falls. When the remaining ductility is less than the next reduction needs, the shell tears at the punch radius. An anneal between stages recrystallises the grain structure and restores formability, at the cost of an extra furnace step, handling and surface cleaning. The process page shows where that step sits in a schedule.
Is a redraw mandatory before an ironing station?
No. When one draw already reaches the required depth, A shallow cup that needs a precise, uniform wall can go straight from the first draw to an ironing station, which is what happens on a simple pressure cup. Ironing is a wall operation, not a depth operation; it is added when the wall specification calls for it, not because the part is tall.
Which process gives the tighter wall tolerance, ironing or redrawing?
Ironing, by a wide margin. A redraw redistributes thickness and leaves a gradient from the base to the rim; we quote ±0.05 mm ID on a normal tool. An ironing pass sets the wall through a controlled gap and, on guided tooling, we hold ±0.02 mm on that wall. The tighter figure is not a process default — it needs the right geometry, lubrication and a stated measurement method.
Key point: A redraw reduces diameter and adds depth; ironing thins and straightens the wall without changing the diameter.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-05 · Reviewed by Sam Zhang, Process Engineer
