Deep Drawing vs CNC Machining: Tolerance Compared

Perforated Drawn Cover Plate with Mounting Holes

Deep drawing holds ±0.05 mm on formed dimensions and ±0.02 mm on features that receive an ironing pass. CNC machining can hold a tighter band on an individual bore or face, but it removes material from solid stock instead of forming a seamless shell in one press line. The right question is not which process is more precise in the abstract, but which features on your drawing actually need the tighter band.

Key point: Use drawing for the seamless shell and the repeatable formed dimensions; use CNC machining only for the features that genuinely need a tighter band, as a secondary operation on the drawn part.

Two different kinds of accuracy

A drawn dimension is repeatable because every part references the same die centreline. Once the draw schedule is proven, diameters and lengths stay consistent across a production run; that is why the deep drawing process is chosen for high-volume seamless housings. The strain-hardening behaviour behind that repeatability is characterised by standard test methods such as ASTM E517 for the plastic strain ratio and ASTM E646 for the strain-hardening exponent; ASM Handbook Volume 14B relates them to forming limits.

Machining accuracy is feature-by-feature. A bore can be finished to a tighter band than a formed wall, but every such feature is a separate setup, and the part is no longer one continuous piece of metal if the housing is built up from machined components. The drawn vs machined vs welded comparison and our CNC machining service explain where each route pays off.

The tolerance bands we quote

±0.05 mm is the standard band on formed dimensions. An ironing pass tightens the wall and bore to ±0.02 mm, and that figure applies to ironing only — not to every geometry and not to a plain redraw. Where a print needs a still tighter feature, we add a sizing or machining pass and state it as a separate operation. Inspection records follow ISO 9001; material certificates for stainless steel sheet reference ASTM A240/A240M.

The practical limit is set by the drawing, not by the process name. Our presses run 5–500 ton, draw to 150 mm depth and return a quote within 24 hours, with a 1,000 piece minimum for new tooling. A capacity page states the numeric bands once so that a buyer can compare routes without reconciling different figures on different pages.

A hybrid route is usually the answer

Most sealed housings are drawn first and machined second: the shell stays seamless, and only the threaded boss, the sealing face or the mounting holes get a finishing pass. Secondary operations covers those steps. If a drawing tolerances every surface, we ask which dimensions are functional — over-tolerancing a formed wall adds cost without improving fit, a point also made in the deep drawn covers guide.

Decision table

requirement better route why
Seamless shell, repeatable diameter Deep drawing One die centreline, one continuous wall
One bore tighter than +/-0.02 mm Draw, then machine that bore Only the functional feature gets the extra pass
Tight wall and bore on a tall can Drawing plus ironing Ironing reaches +/-0.02 mm on formed features
Very low volume, solid block geometry CNC machining No tooling amortisation needed
Flat or shallow bracket Stamping, then machine if needed No deep material flow required

Frequently asked questions

Is CNC machining always more accurate than deep drawing?

On a single feature, yes: a finished bore can be held to a tighter band than a formed wall. Across a whole part, drawing is more repeatable because every dimension references the same die. The two are usually combined rather than competing.

Does the +/-0.02 mm figure apply to every drawn dimension?

No. It applies to features that receive an ironing pass. Our standard formed dimension band is +/-0.05 mm. We state on the quote which features are formed, which are ironed and which are machined, so the print and the process do not drift apart.

Does adding a threaded boss split the drawn wall into two pieces?

Yes. Machining a boss, a thread or a sealing face does not cut the wall in two. What destroys seamlessness is building the housing from separate welded or bolted pieces, which is a different route entirely.

Why does marking every surface with a tight band raise the quote?

Each tighter feature beyond the formed band usually needs a sizing or machining pass, an extra setup and an extra inspection step. Tolerancing dimensions that are not functionally important adds that cost with no gain in fit.

Which steel grades hold the tightest formed tolerances?

Tolerance is governed by the draw schedule and the ironing pass more than by the grade. DC04 with an LDR of 2.1-2.2 forms predictably; 304 stainless steel work-hardens faster at 1.85-2.05 and may need an intermediate anneal before a final sizing pass.

Within what window do we reply with the operations list?

Send the drawing with the dimensions that carry a functional tolerance. We return the stage plan, the operations list and a quote within 24 hours. Tooling is built in-house, so a change to the machining scope does not restart a supplier chain.

What we do not claim: We do not publish leak-rate figures, autoclave cycle counts, springback angles or furnace recipes that we have not measured on our own parts. The ±0.02 mm figure applies to ironing passes only, not to every geometry. 6xxx aluminium is used for shallow forming, not deep drawing. Prices, minimum order quantities and lead times are confirmed per drawing rather than published as fixed values.

Last reviewed: 2026-11-05 · Reviewed by Sam Zhang, Process Engineer. See the full Deep Drawing Engineering Guides hub for process comparisons, measured draw ratios and defect troubleshooting.

Similar Posts