Deep Drawing vs Impact Extrusion for Closed-End Cans

Nickel-Plated Deep Drawn Pressure Vessel Can

Both processes make a seamless closed-end can, but they start from different stock and move metal in different directions. Deep drawing pulls a flat sheet blank radially over a die radius so the sheet flows into a shell; impact extrusion drives a punch into a solid slug so the metal flows backward around the punch. That single difference decides wall uniformity, which alloys are viable and how many operations the part needs.

Key point: Choose deep drawing when you need sheet alloys, progressive dimensional control and in-house tooling; impact extrusion is a single-stroke route from a slug, best suited to ductile low-strength metals.

Two ways to move metal

The patent literature on impact-extruded containers draws the distinction explicitly: most drawing operations start with a flat blank or sheet, whereas impact extrusion uses a slug, and in backward extrusion a solid slug sits in a closed-bottom die while metal flows back over the descending punch. Encyclopaedia Britannica’s metallurgy entry describes the same back-extrusion geometry: the gap between ram and die sets the wall thickness. In drawing, by contrast, a disc of sheet metal is pushed through a die to form a cup, with the blank holder controlling the flange.

Because the starting stock differs, so does the material list. Drawing works from coil or sheet in low-carbon steel, stainless steel, copper, brass and aluminum, with sheet standards such as ASTM A240/A240M for stainless steel. Extrusion needs a ductile slug and is most common with soft aluminum alloys. The extrusion process family covers the forward, backward and combined variants.

What changes on the finished part

A drawn shell is refined stage by stage. Each reduction is an opportunity to correct the geometry, which is why multi-stage drawing is used where dimensional consistency matters; the process types guide lists the routes. Our formed dimensions hold ±0.05 mm, tightening to ±0.02 mm on features that receive an ironing pass. Impact extrusion forms the wall in one high-force stroke, so wall distribution follows the flow pattern of that stroke and tight uniformity usually needs a subsequent ironing or finishing operation.

Tooling is the other practical divider. We design and build drawing tools in-house, so a stage plan or a flange detail can be changed without restarting a supplier chain. Our presses run 5–500 ton, draw to 150 mm depth, and we quote within 24 hours with a 1,000 piece minimum. Seamless tubes and cans shows the drawn route in production, and tool and die design explains the decisions behind it. Quality records follow ISO 9001.

When the other route is the honest answer

If the part is a thick-walled, high-aspect-ratio cylinder in a soft aluminum alloy and the volume is very high, an extruded slug can be the better economic route. We say so during the drawing review rather than forcing every closed-end can onto a drawing press. Where a fabricated or machined construction is more appropriate still, the three-way comparison sets out the trade-offs, and the Engineering Guides hub collects the process comparisons behind that review. What we do not do is quote a pressure or cycle rating we have not measured.

Decision table

requirement deep drawing impact extrusion
Starting stock Flat sheet blank from coil Solid slug cut to volume
Metal flow Radially inward over the die radius Backward around the descending punch
Alloy range Steel, stainless steel, copper, brass, aluminum Mostly ductile low-strength metals
Dimensional control Refined at each reduction Set largely by one stroke, plus finishing
Tooling changes In-house die shop Dedicated slug and die setup

Frequently asked questions

Do both processes produce a seamless closed-end part?

Yes. Neither route joins a separate bottom to a tube, so the closed end and the wall are one continuous piece of metal. The difference is how that continuity is produced: plastic flow of a sheet blank versus displacement of a solid slug.

Which route gives tighter dimensional consistency?

For a thin-walled shell that needs repeatable diameters, multi-stage drawing generally gives more control points because each reduction refines the geometry. We hold +/-0.05 mm on formed dimensions and +/-0.02 mm after an ironing pass on drawn parts.

Why is impact extrusion mostly an aluminum process?

The slug has to flow plastically under a very high compressive load, so soft, ductile, low-strength metals are preferred. Harder alloys and coated steels cause rapid tool wear or surface damage. Drawing accepts a much wider sheet alloy range, including stainless steel.

Can an extruded can be ironed afterwards?

Yes, wall ironing is a recognised finishing step for extruded containers: passing the wall through a punch-and-die gap thins and straightens it. That is a separate operation from the extrusion stroke, not part of it.

What does the starting stock change for material cost?

Drawing generates most scrap at the blanking stage, with coil feeding straight into the press line. Extrusion sizes the slug close to the finished part volume, but slug preparation and handling add upstream steps. The better choice depends on volume and alloy, not on a single material-yield figure.

How do I get a route recommendation for my can?

Send the drawing with diameter, depth, wall, alloy and the functional tolerances. We return a stage plan and a quote within 24 hours. If an extruded slug is the more economical route for that geometry, we state that in the review rather than quoting a drawing tool by default.

What we do not claim: We do not publish leak-rate figures, autoclave cycle counts, springback angles or furnace recipes that we have not measured on our own parts. The ±0.02 mm figure applies to ironing passes only, not to every geometry. 6xxx aluminium is used for shallow forming, not deep drawing. Prices, minimum order quantities and lead times are confirmed per drawing rather than published as fixed values.

Last reviewed: 2026-11-05 · Reviewed by Sam Zhang, Process Engineer. See the full Deep Drawing Engineering Guides hub for process comparisons, measured draw ratios and defect troubleshooting.

Similar Posts